Painting guide
Wallpaper Before a Nashville Repaint: Remove It or Paint Over It?
On this page
You want painted walls. There is wallpaper. Both major manufacturers caution against painting over it: Benjamin Moore recommends removal, and Sherwin-Williams’s painting FAQ says it typically does not recommend painting over wallpaper, while publishing a conditional route for the case where removal is not practical.
That conditional route is the whole question, and whether your wall qualifies for it is something you can establish. The wall decides, and it will tell you in about fifteen minutes if you know what to look at.
Start at a seam and a corner
Take these in the order below, because each one narrows what the next has to consider.
Lift a seam. Find a seam in an inconspicuous place and work a fingernail or a putty knife under the edge. If it lifts readily and keeps lifting, the adhesive has released and the paper is on borrowed time. If it will not lift at all, the bond is intact.
Press across the face. Run a flat hand over a few square feet. Bubbles, soft spots and areas that flex under pressure are places where the paper has already let go behind an intact surface. Those will show through a coating, and they will grow.
Check what the paper is. Vinyl-faced wallpaper has a plastic surface: it feels slick, resists water, and often peels in two layers, a face and a backing. Paper wallpaper absorbs and tears. This matters for both routes, because vinyl resists the water used to remove it and it also resists the water in a waterborne coating.
Look at the corners and behind a switch plate. Corners tell you how many layers there are, and switch plates give you a cross-section. More than one layer of paper is a strong signal, because layers were usually added when removal looked too difficult, and the reason it looked difficult may still be true.
Do this in more than one room. Wallpaper hung at different times behaves differently, and a house is rarely uniform.
What is under the paper
What sits behind the paper is the variable that moves removal from a weekend to a project, and it is worth establishing before committing to either route.
Paper over primed and sealed drywall or plaster is the good case. The adhesive releases with water or a solution and the wall underneath survives.
Paper hung directly on unprimed drywall is the difficult case, and it is common in houses where the paper went up shortly after construction. The adhesive has bonded to the paper facing of the drywall panel itself. Removing the wallpaper can take the facing with it, leaving torn brown paper and exposed gypsum across large areas. That is not a small repair.
Paper on plaster usually removes more cleanly, because plaster is a harder surface and there is no paper facing to lose. Old plaster brings its own complications, and the two are worth telling apart before you start rather than discovering which one you have partway along a wall.
There is a way to test before committing: remove a small section in an inconspicuous area and see what happens. Ten minutes on a two-foot square in a closet tells you more than any amount of general advice.
If that test suggests removal would take the wall with it, the other route needs looking at properly, starting with how it fails.
What happens when you coat over it
Three mechanisms account for most of the cases where the coating-over route goes wrong.
Moisture releases the adhesive. A waterborne coating puts water onto the paper. Wallpaper adhesive is often water-soluble. The result can be bubbling, lifting or peeling that appears during or shortly after painting, in areas where the bond was already marginal.
Seams telegraph. Every seam is a slight ridge or a slight gap. Paint does not fill either. Under a fresh coat the seams often become more visible rather than less, because a uniform sheen across the wall draws the eye to any interruption in it.
Texture comes through. Any embossed or patterned wallpaper keeps its texture under paint, and the pattern stays legible under a solid color. Some people want exactly that. The trouble is that it is rarely a decision anyone made on purpose, because the texture stops registering as a pattern once the color is gone and starts registering as a wall that looks odd.
The route exists and it can be done properly: sealing the paper first with an appropriate product to stop the moisture from reaching the adhesive, treating the seams, and skim coating where the texture would otherwise show. That is not a shortcut. It is a different preparation process with its own labor, and whether it is less work than removal depends entirely on what the removal test showed.
Getting the paper off
Three approaches, two constants and two hazards, and between them they decide whether this is a weekend or something considerably longer.
One of the hazards comes before any of the rest of it. On a pre-1978 wall, anything that scores, scrapes or abrades the painted surface underneath the paper is exactly the activity the federal lead-safe rule is written around, which makes the lead-safe question the first thing to settle: Painting a Pre-1978 Nashville Home: When EPA Lead-Safe Rules May Apply. Stripping a room is not a small job by any measure, which is why this gets answered before the first section comes off rather than when the wall turns out to be in worse condition than expected.
The methods are water with a solution, steam, and dry stripping, and which one suits your wall is settled by the test patch rather than by preference. This page names them and stops there, because a removal procedure is not what it is for.
The risks are worth naming, though, because they decide whether the job is worth taking on. Scoring the paper to let water reach the adhesive can damage the wall underneath if it goes too deep. Steam equipment burns skin and puts a great deal of moisture into a room, usually while somebody is on a ladder. Adhesive residue survives the paper and has to come off completely, because painting over it produces a coating that does not adhere. And the wall has to dry afterwards, which people forget after a day of soaking it.
The part people regret later
Coating over wallpaper makes later removal substantially harder.
The removal methods that work rely on water or solution reaching the adhesive through the paper. A coat of paint over the paper resists exactly that, so the water has to get through the film first. In practice this means scoring the surface to let liquid through, which adds a step, adds time, and adds risk to the wall underneath.
This is worth weighing honestly. If the paper is sound, the seams are tight, the texture is acceptable and you expect to be in the house a long time with no plan to change the walls, coating over is a reasonable decision made with open eyes. If any part of you thinks the paper will come off eventually, it comes off now, when it is easiest.
When coating over is a reasonable choice
Four conditions have to hold at once, and any one of them failing is enough to change the answer.
The paper is bonded everywhere you tested, with no bubbles, no lifting seams and no soft areas. It is a single layer. The removal test in a hidden area showed that removal would damage the wall underneath. And the texture and seams are acceptable to you once you understand they will still be visible.
If all four hold, seal, treat the seams, and paint.
If the first one fails, coating over paper that is already releasing produces a coated wall that is releasing, which is worse.
For everyone the four conditions do not cover, removal it is, and taking that decision properly means knowing what the paper has been hiding.
What removal can expose
What comes off with the paper is the reason removal is a project rather than a task, and it is worth knowing the range before starting.
Under wallpaper you can find: torn drywall facing where the adhesive bonded to the paper layer, gouges from the original installation, unfinished drywall joints that were never taped properly because paper was going over them, plaster cracks that the paper was hiding, adhesive residue that must come off before anything else happens, and occasionally another layer of wallpaper.
Any of those turns a removal into a repair job followed by a painting job. That is normal and it is not a disaster, but it changes the timeline, and it is why removal takes a different amount of work from one wall to the next.
What it also does is add a decision nobody planned for. A stripped wall has to be assessed before any coating goes near it, and that assessment sorts what you uncovered into what has to be repaired, because a coating over it will fail or telegraph, and what a finish will simply cover. Which of your findings falls on which side is taken up in Nashville Interior Repaints: Which Nail Pops, Cracks, and Patches Need Repair?, and it gets settled while the wall is still bare.
Sources. Both manufacturer positions were read on 10 September 2026, and neither of them is an endorsement of painting over wallpaper. Benjamin Moore, How to Remove Wallpaper, states that it “does not recommend” painting over wallpaper, “especially if your wallpaper is high sheen or heavily textured”, and that “even the most premium primer and paint will not hide wallpaper seams”; it also notes that adhesive invisible to the eye can remain after removal and needs sealing before painting. https://www.benjaminmoore.com/en-us/interior-exterior-paints-stains/how-to-advice/painting-101/6-steps-to-remove-wallpaper. Sherwin-Williams states in its painting FAQ that it “typically” does not recommend painting over wallpaper, and sets out a conditional route where removal is not an option: clean the surface, lightly sand the seams, and test a quick-drying alkyd primer on the paper, proceeding only if it dries without lifting or blistering. It also limits that route to nonporous paper. https://www.sherwin-williams.com/en-us/project-center/faqs/paint-faq. Where the two differ, the position of the manufacturer whose product you are using is the one that governs your wall.